Conflict Kitchen faces death threats for presenting a Pro-Palestinian, Anti-Israeli stance

The take-out kiosk Conflict Kitchen, located in Schenley Plaza in Oakland, has reopened after its closure due to death threats because of their decision to serve Palestinian cuisine and present a Pro-Palestinian, Anti-Israeli stance.

Conflict Kitchen serves food from countries with which the United States is in conflict. The kiosk focuses on one country at a time and has previously served food from Afghanistan, Cuba, Iraq, North Korea, and Venezuela.

Conflict Kitchen began serving Palestinian food in October, and the kiosk received pushback from some local populations almost immediately.

According to a Pittsburgh Post-Gazette article from October 7, the day after the opening of Conflict Kitchen’s Palestinian iteration, some Jewish organizations perceived the menu, programming, and promotional materials—including their paper food wrappers containing quotes from interviews with Palestinians from the United States and Gaza—as “anti-Israel” and “one-sided” because they do not represent the Israeli point of view.

The President and Executive Vice President of the Jewish service organization B’nai B’rith International, Allan J. Jacobs and Daniel S. Mariaschin respectively, expressed their concerns about the project in a letter to the Heinz Endowments, which awarded Conflict Kitchen a $50,000 grant last year to aid in its move from East Liberty to Oakland.

Jacobs and Mariaschin stated that they believe Conflict Kitchen’s goals to be incongruent with those of the Heinz Endowments.

Grant Oliphant, President of the Heinz Endowments, responded to B’nai B’rith in a letter and to the general public in a statement on the Heinz Endowments’ website.

“The Endowments has a long and proud history of supporting arts organizations whose work can be challenging or controversial, and I stand firmly with our staff in carrying that tradition forward,” he said in the statement posted on their website.  “While we sometimes do not agree with the ideas presented in the work we fund, we absolutely defend the right of artists and arts organizations to express their work freely and without fear of reprisal.”

In a post on their website, Conflict Kitchen responded by saying, “Promoting understanding is at the core of Conflict Kitchen’s mission.”

“We have demonstrated this in the past by presenting the food, culture, and viewpoints of Iranians, Afghans, Cubans, North Koreans, and Venezuelans,” read the post. “We believe that presenting the viewpoints of Palestinians promotes understanding of Palestinians.”

On November 7, the kiosk received a letter containing death threats because of their menu and programming. They stated on their Facebook page that they would, “be closed until the credibility of the letter [could] be established by the Pittsburgh police.”

In the few days Conflict Kitchen remained closed, locals who support the kiosk’s mission to present the Palestinian viewpoint covered the façade with notes of encouragement.

Several notes expressed Jewish support for Conflict Kitchen’s freedom of representation.

“You are loved and supported by Jewish Students, too! Come back soon,” one message read.

“Dear Friends, My religion is kindness,” read another, which was signed by Rabbi Art Donsky.

Another post containing a drawing of the Star of David and the word, “support,” was affixed to the kiosk’s sign, meaning either Israeli support for Conflict Kitchen, or conversely, support for Israel over Palestine.

Other messages on notebook paper, notecards, and sticky notes contained drawings and encouragements from locals—some of whom took political interest in the controversy and closure, and others of whom simply claimed to be hungry.

One of the simplest messages summed up the general sentiment: “FEED Hunger, NOT Hate.”

As of Wednesday, November 12, Conflict Kitchen has reopened, although the source of the death threats is still under investigation.

“We are overwhelmed by the generous support we have received this week for the project and the rights of Palestinians to present their perspectives without fear of reprisal,” said Conflict Kitchen on their blog. “We are deeply moved by these responses and are excited to reopen and continue our programming.”

Correction 11/18/14: The death threats were not due to serving Palestinian food, but rather the fact that the Conflict Kitchen presented a Pro-Palestinian, Anti-Israeli stance.

Going Global: Timeline of Israel-Gaza Conflict

In June, the Israel-Gaza conflict erupted into all-out fighting over the disappearance of three Israeli boys who were later found murdered in Gaza. This led to one of the bloodiest chapters of the conflict, claiming more than two thousand lives.

June 12:  Naftali Fraenkel, Gilad Shaer, and Eyal Yifrah disappear while hitchhiking in the West Bank, which is part of Palestine. Hamas is blamed for their abduction (and, later, deaths). Operation Brother’s Keeper is launched in an effort to find the missing teens.

June 17:  Operation Brother’s Keeper enters the fifth day. 800 Palestinian civilians are arrested by IDF troops without due process. 40 alleged terror suspects are arrested in connection with the kidnappings, and Palestinian weapons caches are seized.

June 25:  Israeli police spokesman Mickey Rosenfeld admits in a public statement that the kidnappings did not occur with the knowledge or consent of Hamas officials and the actions were of a lone cell not in line with Hamas policies. (This backs up a statement made by Mahmoud Abbas, the Palestinian president, that no evidence had surfaced connecting Hamas with the kidnapping. Rosenfeld retracted his use of the words “lone cell” a few days later.)

June 30:  The bodies of the three missing teens are found in a field north-west of Hebron.  Prime Minister Netanyahu vows to launch a “tough response” to the killings.

Over the course of two weeks, over 1000 areas are raided by IDF forces looking for the missing teens. Claims arose of abuses perpetrated by IDF soldiers, including theft, looting, and destruction of property. Eight Palestinian civilians die during the searches. The homes of two of the kidnapping suspects are bombed by the IDF.

July 1:  Gilad Shaer’s call to an Israeli emergency line is leaked to the public, causing outrage over the fact that the call was not treated with proper care.

Crowds delay the funeral for all three teens over an hour.

20 rockets are fired from Gaza, and the IDF responds with an aerial attack on 34 locations. A Palestinian teen is shot by IDF troops who allege that he threw a grenade; the teen’s family say he was carrying eggs.

July 2:  A Palestinian teen is abducted and murdered by Israeli nationalists. The families of the Israeli teens denounce the kidnappers’ actions.

July 25:  Alleged Hamas member Hussam Qawasmeh is arrested and charged with orchestrating the murders of all three teens; interrogated by Shin Bet (Israel’s internal security service) until he confessed.

July 4 – 30:  Operation Protective Edge is carried out, with the majority of hostile actions perpetrated by IDF forces.  Numerous areas of Palestine are bombed or face Israeli troop movements. The buffer zone around Palestine is extended, reducing the area of safe movement by almost two miles. 25 IDF soldiers are killed in Palestine.

Allegations of the use of DIME bombs (Dense Inert Metal Explosive; typically filled with tungsten, nickel, cobalt, and/or iron) by the IDF arise at a UN hospital at a Gaza refugee camp.

August 20:  Salah al-Aruri, a Hamas official living in exile in Istanbul, blames one of Hamas’ armed wings for the kidnappings and murders (al-Aruri’s statement is considered suspicious, as he may be exaggerating his own role in Hamas in an effort to appear relevant).

August 26:  A ceasefire agreement is reached between Israel and Palestine, with talks to be held in Egypt.

Casualties on the Israeli side of the conflict include 66 soldiers and six civilians (one child was killed); 450 soldiers and 80 civilians are wounded.

Casualties in Palestine (from UN OCHA sources): 2131 dead (1662 are civilians, 490 are children) and 10895 are wounded (3000 of them are children).